How to Respond When Grandparents Challenge Your Parenting Style

Grandparents today, though often well-intentioned, may express criticism or offer advice about your parenting style. While this unsolicited advice can be frustrating, it’s important to remember that these criticisms typically stem from a generational gap in parenting norms. Here are some common criticisms and respectful responses to help share the reasons behind your parenting choices and maintain a positive relationship.

Discipline

You need to be firmer with them. You're too lenient.

Every child is a unique individual, born with their own distinct personality and temperament. Some are easy-going, some slow to adapt, and others challenging. An authoritarian parenting style tends to prioritize obedience and conformity and may make a child feel unloved or misunderstood. If you are challenged in your discipline style, you might respond with, “I’m working on balancing discipline with understanding. I want to foster a healthy relationship based on trust, so I’m trying to approach things a bit differently than we did growing up.”

Comforting Techniques

You need to let the baby cry it out. You’re holding him too much.

Research has now shown the holding and cuddling infants when they cry helps them to grow into happy, secure, well-adjusted children and develop a sense of security and attachment. If you are criticized for comforting your baby when they cry, it may help to say, “I understand that the ‘cry it out’ method worked for you, and I appreciate your perspective. I want to make sure I’m responding to their needs in a way that helps them feel safe and loved, so that’s why I’m choosing to comfort them right now.”

Diaper Choice

Why are you using cloth diapers? It’s so much easier with disposables.

Parents that were forced to use cloth diapers before the development of disposable diapers often don’t understand why one would choose cloth diapers. If you’ve chosen to use cloth diapers, you may need to have a longer conversation with your child’s grandparents about your motivations, which may include environmental benefits of reduced waste, cost-effectiveness, fewer chemicals, or a better option for sensitive skin.  It’s important to share these motivations in a respectful way, such as stating, “I understand that disposables are more convenient, but I prefer cloth diapers for environmental reasons, and I think they’re gentler on their skin.”

No matter what advice you are given or criticism you receive, it is important to acknowledge their experience, set boundaries kindly, and use “I” statements.

Grandparents: Getting Started

Grandparents: Getting Started is taught by certified Safe Sitter® Instructors across the country and teaches grandparents tips to create a good relationship from the start (including avoiding being critical and offering advice!). Use our Find A Class feature to connect with Providers in your area and inquire if they offer this program. If you cannot find a class near you, you can purchase a copy of the Grandparents: Getting Started Participant Handbook. 

Summary

  • Unsolicited parenting advice from grandparents often stems from a generational gap in parenting norms, not bad intentions.
  • When challenged on discipline, acknowledge the difference in approaches and explain that your goal is to build a relationship based on trust — not just obedience.
  • Research now supports responding to infant crying rather than letting babies "cry it out" — framing your response around your child's sense of security can help grandparents understand your choice.
  • If questioned about diaper choice or other practical decisions, share your motivations honestly and respectfully using "I" statements rather than defensiveness.
  • No matter the criticism, acknowledge their experience, set boundaries kindly, and keep the conversation focused on what's best for the child.
  • The Safe Sitter® Grandparents: Getting Started program helps grandparents understand current parenting practices and build a stronger relationship with the families they support.

Quarterly Newsletter

Sign up for the quarterly newsletter to receive parenting tips, program updates, and other resources designed to help you navigate the pre-teen and teen years.

Related Articles

A young woman kneels on the ground, helping a little boy put on his sandals while he sits on a wooden bench in a park.
Your kid wants to babysit, and you're wondering if they're actually ready. Here's what parents...
Read More
things-your-babysitter-wants-you-to-know
Babysitting is tough work. Here are 5 things your sitter secretly wishes you knew —...
Read More
A young child in a red shirt rests their head on a yellow table next to a bowl of colorful cereal, with scattered cereal pieces around them.
You planned on organic baby food and time-outs that actually worked. Then came the Toxic...
Read More