Babysitting Bad Behavior Hacks: How to Get Kids to Behave

Every babysitter hits a wall when the kids just won’t cooperate — and it has nothing to do with whether you’re cut out for the job. This Babysitter Boss episode covers six practical behavior hacks that actually work, from figuring out what’s really wrong to giving kids choices that make them feel heard.

Summary

  • Figure out what's really wrong and address it — a cranky child is often just hungry or tired, and a well-timed snack or nap can turn the whole job around.
  • Distract kids from whatever is upsetting them by asking about their favorite game, toy, or interest — reasoning with a crying child rarely works, but distraction almost always does.
  • If a child has to do something they don't want to do, make a game out of it or offer a fun reward once they finish.
  • Give kids choices instead of constant commands — even small choices help kids feel respected and make them more cooperative.
  • When behavior gets out of hand, use a calm time-out: one minute per year of age, then invite them to start fresh with "let's start over."
  • These hacks work for all ages — adjust your approach based on whether you're dealing with a toddler or a school-aged child.

Video Transcript

My first babysitting experience was a disaster. I mean, the kids were little monsters. They didn’t listen to anything I said. And I just thought, maybe I just suck at babysitting.

After a couple of rough starts, I realized that kids are just kids. And it was up to me, the babysitter, to learn how to manage them. Luckily, I learned a few babysitting hacks to get kids to behave. And today, I’m going to share them with you.

Hack 1: Figure Out What’s Really Wrong and Fix It

If you have a problem with these kids acting up, try this. Figure out what’s really wrong with them and comfort them. You get hangry, right? So does the preschooler you’re watching. Never underestimate the power of a well-timed snack.

Also, little kids need naps. And they get really cranky if they’re tired. Remember to ask their parent about naptime, and for the love of all that’s holy, make sure they get that nap.

Hack 2: Distract Them from Whatever Is Upsetting Them

Distract them. Kids cry. A lot. You may think you can reason with them about why they’re crying, but yeah, good luck with that. But it’s pretty easy to distract them from whatever it is that’s upsetting them. Just ask them about their favorite game or toy. This works for older kids too. Just be prepared for a long conversation about their Minecraft village.

Hack 3: Make Chores or Transitions Into a Game

If they have to do something they don’t want to do, like clean up their toys or get ready for bed, make a game out of it. You can also promise them something fun as a reward once they finish a toy.

When you pick up your toys, then we can watch a movie. Okay.

Hack 4: Give Kids Choices Instead of Commands

Give them choices. You don’t like it when parents and teachers constantly tell you what to do. So, don’t be bossy to the kids you’re babysitting. Find a way to give them choices. Even if it’s about things that aren’t very fun.

Hack 5: Use the Time-Out Do-Over Technique

Take a break, start over. Some people call this a time-out, but I like to think of it as a do-over. Kids appreciate the chance to start over, so stay calm, and tell them that you want them to take a break for a few minutes. Three minutes for a 3-year-old, four minutes for a 4-year-old, you get the idea. Then say, Let’s start over.

Babysitting doesn’t have to be disastrous. Use these bad behavior hacks and I promise you’ll be a Babysitter Boss before you know it.

Babysitter Boss Videos

A young babysitter wearing blue gloves tends to a child's scraped arm in a bathroom setting, demonstrating first aid skills.
Babysitting can involve more than games and snacks—you may also need to handle minor injuries...
Watch Video
A young girl in a red striped shirt lays on the floor making a scrunched-up face, while another child in a blue dress sits nearby with toys. A babysitter observes from a chair in the background.
What do you do when the toddler you are babysitting refuses to have their diaper...
Watch Video
The image shows Babysitter Boss, Lexi, seated confidently against a dark background, participating in a promotional interview. Lexi is wearing a white t-shirt with the Safe Sitter® logo, featuring a colorful design, paired with light blue jeans. Her relaxed posture and friendly expression convey approachability and professionalism. Next to her, a large poster on an easel prominently displays the "Babysitter Boss by Safe Sitter®" branding, with a playful design featuring clouds and a smiling baby logo. The hashtag "#BabysitterBoss" at the bottom of the poster emphasizes a call to action or engagement with the audience. This scene highlights Lexi as a central figure representing the Babysitter Boss series, showcasing her role as a relatable and knowledgeable mentor for young babysitters.
Watch behind the scenes footage and get Lexi’s take on the series, Babysitter Boss by...
Watch Video
A babysitter with curly hair and a calm, neutral expression listens attentively to a child, whose back is facing the camera.
There are several reasons kids don’t listen but don’t lose heart, there are also several...
Watch Video
A happy female teen sits on a couch, smiling as cash bills fall around her.
Dreaming of becoming a babysitter but not sure where to start? This video lays out...
Watch Video